first photo of white beautiful fence
Updated:
9/17/25
by Cedar Rustic Fence Co.

The Definitive Guide to Choosing a Professional Fence Company in the Chicagoland

It’s mid-winter, you’re staring out at your yard, and your old fence is barely holding it together through another brutal snowstorm. You’ve put it off long enough — it’s finally time for an upgrade. In Chicago, the weather doesn’t make it easy. We go from subzero wind chills to humid 90-degree summers, and those temperature swings wreak havoc on outdoor structures.

Finding a qualified fencing company that understands these local conditions is critical for installing a fence that will stand strong for decades while meeting Chicago's specific building codes.

Why Hiring the Right Fence Contractor Matters

Selecting a professional fence installer isn't just about convenience — it's about ensuring your investment remains secure for years to come. The expertise a specialized fencing contractor brings can make all the difference in your fence's longevity and performance.

  1. ‍Structural problems: If the posts aren’t set deep enough or the wrong materials are used, your fence could lean, sag, or even collapse, especially once freeze-thaw cycles start shifting the ground.‍
  2. Permit mistakes: Chicago has specific requirements for fence construction. If your contractor ignores them, you could end up facing code violations, fines, or even having to rebuild the fence from scratch.
    1. Naperville: Has detailed design standards that vary by neighborhood, like the historic district, with some areas prohibiting certain materials in front yards.‍‍
    2. Joliet: Mandates visibility triangles on corner lots and requires detailed site plans showing the fence location relative to utilities and easements before permit approval.‍‍
    3. Aurora: Enforces strict height limitations with different rules for corner properties and requires structural engineering approval for fences over 6 feet in commercial zones.‍‍
    4. Elgin: Has specific wind load requirements for fence construction and requires proof of property ownership or written permission from property owners before permit issuance.‍‍
    5. Oak Forest: Follows International Residential Code standards with emphasis on proper foundation depth and structural stability to withstand local weather conditions.‍
  3. Home value: A properly installed fence can boost your property’s value by up to 5%. A sloppy one, on the other hand, might turn buyers off entirely.
Note: While DIY fence installation might appear cost-effective initially, professional fence installation ensures longevity, especially given our region's extreme seasonal changes. A reputable contractor brings expertise in selecting high-quality materials that will withstand Chicago's harsh weather conditions.

What to Look for When Choosing a Fence Contractor in Chicago

Top 5 Contractor Red Flags (That Aren’t Obvious)

If you’re asking yourself “How do I choose a fence company?”, the answer starts with knowing what separates a real pro from someone who cuts corners. The right contractor brings more than tools — they bring accountability, planning, and a track record of solid results.

Proper Licensing and Registration

Always confirm that your contractor is licensed and registered in the Chicagoland Area. This isn’t just a formality — it shows they’re legally approved to build fences in your area and that they’ve taken the proper steps to work within local guidelines. Skip this step, and you’re taking an unnecessary risk.

Full Insurance Coverage Matters

Don’t take chances on what-ifs. Your contractor should carry both liability insurance and workers' compensation so you're not left covering the cost of injuries or damage on your property. Always ask for proof, and double-check with the insurance provider to confirm the policy is active.

Full Insurance Coverage Matters

Fence Work Should Be Their Specialty

The best results come from professionals who focus on fencing as their main trade, not as a side offering. Ask to see photos of past projects and make sure they’ve worked with the material you want — vinyl, wood, and metal fences all require different skills to install properly.

Check Reviews and Local References

Don’t just rely on star ratings — dig deeper. Look at review platforms, the BBB, and request recent local references. Pay close attention to how they handled tough installs and whether past clients were satisfied with the overall experience.

Taking time upfront to carefully research your options will save you from major headaches later. Many homeowners have faced the nightmare of a project costing them double after selecting a cheap, unqualified contractor.

What Questions Should I Ask a Fence Contractor?

Asking targeted questions helps separate truly professional fence installers from those who might deliver subpar results. The responses you receive provide valuable insights into a potential contractor's expertise, process, and reliability.

How long have you specialized in fence installation, and can you show me similar projects you've completed in Chicagoland?

This helps you gauge their hands-on experience with your type of fence and whether they’ve worked in your area before. Reputable contractors are happy to walk you through past projects that match what you’re planning.

What fence materials would you recommend for our Chicago climate, and why?

Their answer should reflect a real understanding of how different materials perform through freezing winters and hot, humid summers. The best contractors will explain what’s ideal for your yard and your long-term budget.

Will you provide a written warranty for both materials and labor, and what exactly does it cover?

Most professional contractors offer a workmanship warranty that lasts at least 1 to 3 years. Material warranties vary by product type. Get it all in writing — including what’s excluded — before the work starts.

Keep copies of everything: your signed contract, warranty terms, permit approvals, and any care instructions. These records are helpful for future maintenance and increase your home’s resale value by showing that professional work was done.

How to Compare Fence Contractor Quotes

If you’re searching “how to choose a fence contractor”, you may go with the first result, assuming it’s a reputable company and it feels reasonably priced. However, comparing multiple quotes may give you a better sense of pricing and help you avoid lowball bids that often come with hidden problems.

Every quote should be detailed. That means you’re not just getting a single number — you’re getting a full breakdown of materials, labor, permits, and other costs.

Here’s what to watch for:

  • Material specifications (exact type, grade, and quantity)
  • Permit acquisition fees and who handles the process
  • Post-installation cleanup procedures
  • Detailed project timeline with start and completion dates
  • Payment schedule with clear milestones
  • Warranty terms for both materials and workmanship

Be wary of quotes that come in 15% to 20% lower than the rest. It might mean they’re cutting corners on materials or hiring less experienced labor. In Chicago, especially, fence posts need to be set deep and solid to survive the freeze-thaw cycles. Skimping here causes problems later.

Don’t feel like you need to talk with 10 different contractors — you’ll end up spending too much time and effort, when one of the first you’ve seen will do the job and do it well.

Making Your Final Decision: Next Steps

Choosing a fence company takes a bit of homework, but it’s worth every minute. A solid contractor gives you peace of mind, protects your investment, and delivers a fence that actually holds up year after year.

If you're looking for a trusted local team, Cedar Rustic Fence Co. checks all the boxes — licensed, experienced, and backed by decades of positive reviews. We've been helping Chicago homeowners since 1927. Contact us today to schedule your free consultation and see why we’ve earned the trust of thousands of local families.

vinyl fence

Need help making a decision?

Contact us today and let's explore your options.

Free estimate

We are Cedar Rustic Fence Company ;) Nailing expertise in fencing for nearly a century. We've seen it all, from picket perfection to backyard beast-proofing. Your fence needs are in good hands.

Similar Posts

Updated:
9/17/25
By Cedar Rustic Fence Co.

Understanding Your Fence Investment: A Complete Cost Guide

Planning a fence project in Chicagoland? Understand the real costs with our complete pricing guide covering materials, installation, permits, and money-saving strategies.

Read Article
Updated:
9/16/25
By Cedar Rustic Fence Co.

6 Cedar Fence Ideas That Will Wow Your Neighbors

Discover 6 stunning cedar fence ideas and find your perfect style with Cedar Rustic Fence Co. Take our quick quiz!

Read Article
Load More